Sport Rider Homepage
Get Adobe Flash player
Comparison Test BMW Suzuki

2009 BMW K1300S vs. Suzuki Hayabusa - Warp Speed Ahead

It's Brain Vs. Brawn As The 2009 BMW K1300S Takes On The 2009 Suzuki Hayabusa In A High Speed Showdown
By Troy Siahaan
Photography by Kevin Wing
Don't look now but BMW is on the charge. Long known for building awkward boxer twins or comfortable inline fours that appeal to the more-ahem-older crowd, if you've purchased a BMW lately chances were likely an AARP membership was also on its way to your mailbox. Nobody wants to be known as that guy and now Bavarian Motor Works is doing something about it. For those who were paying attention, the HP2 line of performance-oriented boxer twins was the proverbial knock on the door to the younger demographic, but this year that door is being busted wide open with the introduction of the company's first superbike, the S 1000 RR, and the revamping of its flagship-the K1200S-into the more powerful K1300S. Both models aimed directly at its Japanese competition. So with the obvious challenge in plain sight, we decided to pit the German challenger against the Japanese king of the mountain-the Suzuki Hayabusa. At this point you've probably noticed a distinct member of the party is missing: Kawasaki's ZX-14. That's no mistake. Past showdowns between the 'Busa and 14 have resulted in the Suzuki edging the Kawasaki in our overall scores mainly because of its handling advantage. Power plants were mainly on par, with the Kawasaki getting a better jump off the line, but the Suzuki has the edge in peak horsepower. The Suzuki won, but by no means was it a blowout. So with one contender out of the way it was time for someone else to try and knock the Suzuki.

Means To An End
Both of these machines do one thing really well: go fast, really fast, especially in a straight line. But the methodologies by which each machine gets there are vastly different. We've covered both bikes in detail before, the Hayabusa last year in the April issue ("Big Numbers", April '08) and the K1300S in Kento's first ride piece in the June '09 issue ("Bavarian Brawn"). Both bikes were the benefactors of displacement increases during their major redesigns (the Suzuki's in 2007); the Suzuki up to 1340cc (from 1298cc) and the BMW 1293cc (from 1157cc). Beyond that, combustion chambers for both bikes have been revised to promote more swirl. For the Hayabusa, piston shape was slightly altered, resulting in a 12.5:1 compression ratio, rings received ion plating treatment to reduce friction, and titanium is the metal of choice for the intake and exhaust valves. Of course, this is old news by now as the bike has been out for three years.

Community Comments

tclause  (10/15/09 09:32 PM)

I can not believe the test on this. what real performance comparison was there no 0-06 no 0-100 no 0-186 no track comparison. Typical seat of the pants o-meter testing I own a K8 Hayabusa and find it to be the finest all around motorcycle I have ever ridden and that's with thirty years of riding performance motorcycles. I am tired of the take a poke at the king mentality. The writers of this artical know that the hayabusa will destroy the bmw in every performance aspect except for maybee braking. I recommend you think hard before buying the bmw because guys like me will be waiting to give you that Busa beating you will have earned. here are there own performane numbers from thier own test chart on the  Hayabusa ('08) 4/08 9.68 @ 148.3 2.57 2.75 n/a better than the bmw huh. Maybee a typo ?

ducati800ss  (10/20/09 02:39 PM)

I find the comparison tests of very high powered motorcycles to be quite trivial. Both bikes in this comparison are incredible machines and one certainly is not better than the other. At this level of performance it comes down to personal preference of the rider. Both bikes have the highest "bragging" rights so to speak when compared to just about any other bike on the planet. The performance maximum for just about any motorcycle built today far exceeds any street legal limit, so pushing these bikes to the max by most riders will cause them to lose their license or bike, or get injured or killed. Let's forget about emphasizing performance numbers and concentrate on articles about how to drive these incredible machines smoothly and safely.

tclause  (10/20/09 09:13 PM)

Apples and Oranges was my point. The bmw is not comparable in my opinion the zx14 is. I was talking about the method of testing. You can not get around hard numbers in this kind of comparison. Performance is the lifes blood of hyper sports market, that's the point I am trying to make. I was not condoning Crazy Street Riding and I am an advocate of proper training.

ducati800ss  (10/22/09 04:18 AM)

I agree with tclause that the method of testing for articles such as these are suspect. You can take any set of parameters on any two or more bikes that are "very close" so to speak, and easily make one bike look better than the other. The "hype" of the articles is what helps to sell magazines. The comparison test articles need to be "taken with a grain of salt" and should be enjoyed for their entertainment value more than anything.
It's great when the comparison articles such as this one do generate passion, because that is what motorcycling is all about.

tclause  (10/22/09 09:09 PM)

Thanks for your input ducati800ss. I would also like to thank you for your composure when you refered to me as passionate.

JackCurry  (11/08/09 08:41 AM)

Iam a BMW K1300S 2009 owner. And I also own two of the best sport bikes in the world. CBR 1000RR and Ducati 1098r. I believe there is more to the life of a motorcycle riding than going fast in a straight line.I purchase the BMW K1300S after a demo ride I very happy with the overall performance and handling,I now have 3500 mls on the bike, I have also have taken the bike to twice to the Arkansas mountains with great pleasure. The bike is the best for a person who wants to sport tour at fast pace. I highly recommend this bike.
Happy Motoring

Post a Comment (Must Be Registered)


User Name
Not Registered? Signup Here
Password
Comment
   (1024 character limit)
Get Adobe Flash player
Dodge Dakota Research
Dodge Dakota With great deals and authoritative reviews, find all you need to research and buy the new Dodge Dakota, as well as compare it with other vehicles to help you in your car buying process. The 2010 Dakota comes with a V6 standard engine and has a manufacturer suggested retail price of $31,995.00. It has a 5 star frontal impact rating for the driver and a 5 star frontal impact rating for the passenger. Also check out the Nissan 350Z and the BMW M3.

Related Photos

Comparison Test HP TQ Graph Comparison Test K1300S Cockpit
Comparison Test Tjhree Quarter Front View Comparison Test Hayabusa Cockpit